Year of Award
2011
Document Type
Thesis
Degree Type
Master of Arts (MA)
Degree Name
Philosophy
Department or School/College
Department of Philosophy
Committee Chair
Christopher Preston
Commitee Members
Cara Nelson, Matthew Strohl
Keywords
aesthetics, Allen Carlson, anti-formalism, Emily Brady, environmental ethics, environmental protection, Kendall Walton, Marcia Eaton, natural world, Ned Hettinger, Noel Carroll, preservation, scientific cognitive model, beauty, environmentalism
Publisher
University of Montana
Abstract
Aesthetics has played an influential role in how we ascribe value to the environment. Yet, it seems that if we are to take the beauty of the natural world seriously, certain aesthetics judgments must be better than others. The scientific cognitive model posits that the natural world must be interpreted through an understanding of biological and geological categories, which are provided by scientific knowledge and common sense. While there are clearly merits to this model, it is not without its own set of problems and limitations. These problems exist in both the model itself and with its extension to environmental ethics. This thesis functions as an analysis and critique of this particular model, suggesting that it should not be thought of as comprehensive in both a descriptive and a normative sense, nor relied on exclusively for environmental decision making. I suggest two other models of aesthetic appreciation that can and should exist alongside the scientific cognitive model, eventually settling on a position of constrained pluralism.
Recommended Citation
Hays, John K., "Aesthetic Appreciation of the Natural Environment: Scientific Knowledge & the Extension from Aesthetics to Ethics" (2011). Graduate Student Theses, Dissertations, & Professional Papers. 104.
https://scholarworks.umt.edu/etd/104
© Copyright 2011 John K. Hays