ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY OF FUEL REDUCTION TREATMENTS IN THE HOME IGNITION ZONE TO MITIGATE WILDFIRE RISK IN MONTANA, USA

Author

Howard L. Williams, hw176332Follow

Year of Award

2015

Document Type

Thesis

Degree Type

Master of Science (MS)

Degree Name

Forestry

Department or School/College

College of Forestry and Conservation

Committee Chair

Tyron Venn

Commitee Members

Karin Riley, Kevin McManigal, Tony Prato

Keywords

wildfire, risk, economic, evaluation, wildland urban interface

Publisher

University of Montana

Subject Categories

Natural Resource Economics

Abstract

Wildland-urban interface growth and factors increasing the probability of wildfire suggest that annual spending on wildfire risk mitigation and suppression will continue to increase. With limited information about the benefits and costs of risk mitigation, land managers and homeowners may under- or over-invest in risk mitigation, where costs are disproportionate to the expected benefits of the strategy. This study accounted for expected increases in wildfire risk (due to growth of the WUI, climate change and vegetation growth) over time in Flathead County, Montana, and estimated the expected avoided loss in structure values associated with three treatment levels that would require homeowners to treat fuels on their properties. Expected avoided losses were then compared with estimates of the expected cost of implementing and maintaining the treatments over time. The majority of the WUI (86%-99%) received no more than $100 of benefit per structure, as measured by the expected avoided losses due to treatment, under all home ignition zone treatment levels. Comparison of the mean annualized treatment costs suggests the light treatments are economically efficient for about 1% of study area structures. Heavy treatments are likely to be efficient for about 3% of study area structures, and full treatments for about 2% of study area structures. Therefore, the analysis strongly suggests that mandatory fuel treatments for home-owners are unlikely to be economically efficient in Flathead County. These findings are robust to the parameter changes explored in the sensitivity analysis, in which a 20% and 50% increase and decrease in wildfire risk was conducted.

Recommended Citation

Williams, Howard L., "ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY OF FUEL REDUCTION TREATMENTS IN THE HOME IGNITION ZONE TO MITIGATE WILDFIRE RISK IN MONTANA, USA" (2015). Graduate Student Theses, Dissertations, & Professional Papers. 4575.
https://scholarworks.umt.edu/etd/4575