Year of Award

2022

Document Type

Dissertation

Degree Type

Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)

Degree Name

Organismal Biology, Ecology, and Evolution

Department or School/College

Division of Biological Sciences

Committee Chair

Douglas J. Emlen

Commitee Members

H. Arthur Woods, Bret W. Tobalske, Erick Greene, Sven Bradler

Keywords

allometry, assessment strategy, convergent evolution, flight, Phasmatodea, sexual selection

Abstract

How has the diversity of life forms come to be? This question is at the core of evolutionary biology and can be addressed at different scales: by studying the processes that drive modifications within populations of organisms generation after generation (microevolution), or by investigating patterns of changes on the tree of life over long periods of time (macroevolution). Understanding the ultimate drivers of morphological diversity eventually entails connecting microevolutionary processes with macroevolutionary patterns. My dissertation investigates the diversification of body and egg form and its drivers in a relatively small but particularly diverse insect order: the stick and leaf insects (Phasmatodea).

As masters of camouflage, the 3,400 described species of phasmids are an ideal system to study morphological evolution as they vary tremendously in body morphology, going from long slender branch mimics to wide, flat animals that look exactly like leaves. This remarkable diversity of forms enables phasmids to avoid detection by visually-hunting predators. Even their remarkably diverse hardshelled eggs resemble a wide variety of plant seeds. In addition, males and females of the same species often look very different from each other, with females in extreme cases more than ten times the size of the males.

In chapters one, two and three, I investigate the patterns of variation of female body morphology, sexual dimorphism and egg morphology respectively, and potential ecological, life history and biomechanical correlates in a phylogenetic context. I describe repeated convergence towards multiple body forms associated with habitat transitions but find substantial variation in the strength of convergence and underlying evolutionary paths. Then, I show that variation in the extent of sexual dimorphism is best explained by variation in selective pressures acting on males, namely locomotor (flight) performance and male competition (sexual selection). Finally, I show that variation in egg size and shape is driven by variation in life history strategies, mechanical constraints and oviposition strategy.

In chapters four, five and six, I investigate the microevolutionary processes behind the primary macroevolutionary forces driving variation in sexual dimorphism. In chapter four, I show in leaf insects (Phyllium philippinicum) that larger males are poor flyers, suggesting that selection for flight performance favors smaller male body sizes in this species, and reinforcing the broader taxonomic findings of chapter two. In chapters five and six, I describe how a change in the mating system of thorny devil stick insects (Eurycantha calcarata) switched the direction of sexual selection and led to the evolution of exceptionally large male body sizes and exaggerated hindleg weapons, confirming the pervasive role of sexual selection in driving variation in male size and sexual dimorphism. Collectively, my research contributes to our understanding of the forces that shape the evolution of morphology in animals and their eggs.

Download

Share

COinS
 

© Copyright 2022 Romain Pascal Gilbert Eric Boisseau